*Spoilers ahoy!*
I voted “yes” on The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo for our book club recently because it’s been so hugely popular for so long that I just had to see what was up.
I don’t know why I keep doing that because I am almost always disappointed (an exception: Water for Elephants,by Sara Gruen).
I did like the character of Lisbeth Salander, the eponymous tattoo-bearer. She’s unlike anyone you’ve encountered in a popular work of fiction–extremely intelligent, brittle, lacking in social graces, yet earning the reader’s sympathy and support all the same.
The book’s plot can be riveting, as its heroes–Lisbeth and a journalist named Mikael Blomkvist–try to solve a 40-year-old crime. But there are long discussions of Swedish politics and financial practices that left me completely confused and bored. The book was written by a now deceased Swedish writer, Stieg Larsson, and is the first of a Lisbeth trilogy. Since I don’t speak any Swedish, I don’t know whether to blame the author or the translator for the novel’s style-free writing. Its words serve only to advance the plot, not to paint vivid pictures or make readers stop and treasure a particularly lovely turn of phrase. Worse yet were the constant references to specific products and brand names. It felt like an episode of The Biggest Loser. Product placement gone haywire!
Still, I read on, wanting to know what happened to the long-ago crime victim, and to Lisbeth too (Mikael? eh). But the solved mystery turned out to be just a small cog in a larger wheel. A wheel of blood, guts, sadism, and gore. It seemed contrived, inelegant, and altogether unnecessary.
To be fair, I rarely read the mystery/thriller genre. I’d probably have the same complaints about many books of this type. But I’m left wondering why this one, in particular, has captivated so many. Is it the unusual female lead? The fact that the author died just after delivering the manuscripts for the three books? ‘Cause I’m stumped.
Have you read it? What did you think?
Visit Kirsetin at The Hip Mom’s Guide for more Bibliophile Friday.